Key Takeaways
• Principal-and-interest repayments pay down both the loan and the interest, so you steadily build equity and clear the debt by the end of the term.
• Interest-only repayments cover just the interest for a set period, so they are lower at first, but the loan balance does not reduce, and you pay more interest overall.
• When an interest-only period ends, repayments jump as you start repaying the principal over a shorter remaining term, which can be a shock.
• P&I suits most owner-occupiers; interest-only suits specific situations, and is more tightly assessed by lenders, so it pays to understand both.
When you take out a home loan, one of the choices you will face is how you repay it: principal-and-interest, or interest-only. The difference may sound technical, but it has a significant effect on your repayments now, your equity over time, and the total interest you pay. Getting it right matters.
For most owner-occupiers, principal and interest is the natural choice, but interest-only has its place. In this guide, we will explain how each works, the pros and cons, the payment shock to watch for, and who each one tends to suit, so you can choose with confidence.
The right repayment type depends on your goals and your cash flow, and the wrong one can cost you. If you would like to weigh up your options, our home loan team at Loan Street Finance is happy to compare both options for your situation, at no cost and with no pressure.
How Each Type Works
The names describe exactly what you repay, so the mechanics are simpler than they sound.
With principal-and-interest, every repayment covers two things: the interest charged, plus a slice of the principal, the amount you borrowed. Over time, the balance shrinks, and the loan is fully repaid by the end of the term. With interest-only, your repayments cover just the interest for a set period, usually one to five years. Your repayments are lower during that time, but the balance does not budge. When the interest-only period ends, the loan switches to principal-and-interest for the remaining term.
Principal-and-Interest Loans
This is the standard choice for people buying a home to live in, and for good reason.
The Advantages
Because every repayment chips away at the balance, you build equity steadily and own your home outright at the end of the term. You pay less interest over the life of the loan than you would with interest-only, and the interest rate is often lower, too. There is also no future jump in repayments to brace for.
The Trade-Offs
The main downside is simply that repayments are higher than interest-only in the early years, because you are paying down the loan as well as the interest. For some budgets, that extra monthly cost is a genuine consideration.
Interest-Only Loans
Interest-only can be useful in the right circumstances, but it asks for a clear understanding of the trade-offs.
The Advantages
The obvious appeal is lower repayments during the interest-only period, which can ease cash flow. This can suit investors, people expecting a short-term dip in income, those building a home, or borrowers who want to direct spare cash elsewhere, such as into an offset account. For a defined period and a clear purpose, it can be a sensible tool.
The Trade-Offs
The catch is that you build no equity during the interest-only period, the balance stays the same, and you pay more interest over the life of the loan. The rate is often higher, lenders assess these loans more strictly, and when the period ends, your repayments rise, sometimes sharply. Interest-only is a short-term strategy, not a way to make an unaffordable loan affordable.
The Payment Shock to Watch For
This is the single most important thing to understand about interest-only, and it catches people out.
When an interest-only period ends, you must repay the full principal over a shorter remaining term. Say you have a 30-year loan with a five-year interest-only period: once it ends, you repay the whole balance over the remaining 25 years, not 30. That compresses the principal into fewer years, so your repayments jump, often well above what they would have been on principal-and-interest from the start. Lenders know this, which is why they assess your ability to afford the higher, post-interest-only repayment from the outset, not just the lower interest-only one.
A Real-World Example: The Numbers Compared
Here is an illustration with rounded figures showing how the two compare and where the shock comes in. Treat it as a guide only.
Take a $520,000 loan at around 6.50% over 30 years. On principal-and-interest, the repayment is about $3,287 a month for the whole term, steadily reducing the balance. On interest-only, you would pay about $2,817 a month during the interest-only period, around $470 less, but the balance would not reduce at all.
Now the catch. If the interest-only period is five years, once it ends, you repay the $520,000 over the remaining 25 years, and the repayment jumps to about $3,511 a month, higher than the $3,287 you would have paid on principal-and-interest from day one. Over the full loan term, interest-only costs you more in total interest because you spent years not reducing the balance.
Lower now, higher later, and more in the end: that is the interest-only trade-off in a nutshell. It can still be worth it for the right purpose, but the numbers need to suit your plan.
How to Decide Which Suits You
A few questions help you land on the right repayment type.
• Ask whether your goal is to own the home outright, which points to principal-and-interest.
• Be clear on why you would want interest-only, and for how long.
• Make sure you can afford the higher repayment when an interest-only period ends.
• Factor in the higher total interest and often a higher rate of interest-only.
• Get advice if your situation is more complex, such as investing or building.
For most people buying a home to live in, principal and interest is the straightforward, lower-cost choice. Interest-only is a tool for specific jobs, used with eyes open.
Where to Read More
It helps to understand the types of repayment from an independent source before you decide. The Australian Government's MoneySmart service explains how interest-only home loans work, including the jump in repayments when an interest-only period ends.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
What is the difference between interest-only and principal-and-interest?
With principal-and-interest, your repayments pay off both the interest and the loan itself, so the balance reduces over time. With interest-only, you pay just the interest for a set period, so the balance stays the same and repayments are lower for a while. After that period, interest-only switches to principal-and-interest.
Are interest-only repayments cheaper?
Only in the short term. Interest-only repayments are lower during the interest-only period because you are not paying down the loan. But because the balance does not reduce, and the rate is often higher, you pay more interest over the life of the loan. The early savings are borrowed against at a higher cost later.
What happens when an interest-only period ends?
Your repayments rise, often noticeably. Once the interest-only period ends, you repay the full balance over the shorter remaining term, which pushes the repayment above what straight principal-and-interest would have been. This is sometimes called payment shock, and it is why lenders check that you can afford it from the start.
Who should consider an interest-only loan?
It tends to suit specific situations rather than the average owner-occupier. Investors, people expecting a temporary drop in income, those building a home, or borrowers maximising an offset may have good reasons. The key is a clear purpose and a defined period, not using it simply to reduce repayments on a loan you would otherwise struggle to repay.
Is it harder to get an interest-only loan?
Often, yes. Lenders and regulators treat interest-only more cautiously, especially for owner-occupiers. You generally need to show you can afford the higher repayment that applies once the interest-only period ends, so qualifying can be tighter than for principal-and-interest.
Does interest-only cost more in the long run?
Generally, yes. Because you do not reduce the balance during the interest-only period, more of your money goes to interest and less to the principal, so the total interest over the life of the loan is higher. That is the trade-off for the lower repayments early on.
The Bottom Line
The choice between interest-only and principal-and-interest comes down to what you are trying to achieve. Principal-and-interest steadily builds equity, clears the loan, and costs less in total interest, which is why it suits most people buying a home to live in. Interest-only lowers your repayments for a set period, useful for specific purposes, but you build no equity in that time, pay more interest overall, and face a jump in repayments when the period ends.
Neither is inherently better; it depends on your goals, your cash flow, and whether you have a clear reason to choose interest-only. The most important thing is to go in with an understanding of the trade-offs, especially the payment shock. If you would like help comparing the two for your situation, we would be glad to walk you through the numbers.